Our Reviews

I feel extremely lucky to have found Fifth Ave Eye Care and Dr. Gorman who installed new lenses for me in 2012. Thanks h the o his expertise my eyes came out extremely well and are still good (20/20 without glasses) after 9 years. The whole establishment is well run: professional yet super friendly. I just heard that, alas, Dr. Gorman will be retiring soon, but I am sure the others at Fifth Avenue are equally good.

My best experience yet, with eye doctors.For years I have been having eye issues, from very dry eyes to drooping eyelids that limited my vision. Dr Rosenthal is the one who finally divulged my condition, and recommends permanent solutions.I was referred to him by a friend who also sees doctors there. I am grateful to have found Dr Rosenthal, and I would recommend him and his establishment to anyone seeking eye care professionals.

From the moment we were greeted at the door until we left, we were treated professionally. I felt very assured, each procedure was explained to me I understand what to expect at my next visitFran Busch.

Dr. Kenneth Rosenthal and his staff were consistently professional and competent from the start. His assistants also demonstrated sophistication in the use of the numerous medical instruments that are found in his large office suite, also taking care to carefully and courteously explain the results. Dr. Rosenthal's true talent as a cataract surgeon was most obvious when he operated on my more challenging eye as I could literally feel the intensity of his work, painless, as he performed the procedure. When I walked in, I probably had about 50% of the better eye, but perhaps only 20% of the traumatized one. Almost at the end of this long procedure now, my vision is close to what it was as a young man, at least 95% better. Dr. Rosenthal is a compassionate, patient, knowledgeable surgeon, expert in his field! Mark Shapiro

i met dr rosenthal tuesday 6/22/21.I was looking to do cataract surgeryon both eyes,.i told dr rosenthal that if dr gorman recommended me to him,,i knew he was the right dr for me.Upon speaking to dr rosenthal at first, i got a warm feeling from him as a caring dr and one who made you feel comfortable about getting eye surgery.He explained to me the options, and was quite sufficent in detail..i felt very comfortable with dr rosenthal and realized he was quite professional in handling all the specific details that i needed to know about cataract surgery.He was quite low key and quite friendly,which i feel is necessary when choosing a dr.In addition,the dr made me quite relaxed and comfortable in his presence.Therefore, i felt going forward with my procedure, was just a matter of timing.I feel very confident in reccommending dr rosenthal to any of my friends or family members.ELLIOT ADER