Our Reviews

Great experience with Dr Rosenthal. Not only is he a brilliant doctor, he is very caring and treats my mother like his mother. We have full confidence in his abilities and know that we are in the right hands. His office is very attentive, Rita, Berta and Danielle have been amazing to work with. It really was our good fortune to be recommended

I have been struggling with multiple surgeries and conditions for 6 years and this wonderful practice has taken me through the worst. Most recently, Dr Scherk and I have been on a one year experimental journey to combat a frustrating new condition and I'm happy to say that we have won the battle! Thank you all for taking such good care of me.

Everyone in the office were extremely professional, nice and made me feel very comfortable during my eye tests. Everyone was so in sync with each other. It was the best experience I ever had in a doctors office.

I was able to get an appointment at short notice which was really important because I had a lot of discomfort.

The care and explanations were exceedingly thorough, and I felt like I was in wonderful hands! I strongly recommend Fifth Avenue Eyecare!